Mysterious Merchant
Mysterious Merchant is a live-action quest-based social event that I have built up over the last 3 years. I created the experience to push DigiPen students outside of their comfort zones by participating in fun and humorous quests that encourage social interaction. I perform as both the Shopkeeper and Quest Master NPCs, each of whom have distinct voices and personalities intended to create more immersion. Completing a quest awards gold coins that can be spent in the shop to acquire fantasy-themed items from the Mysterious Merchant universe.
Mysterious Merchant Worldbuilding
This is a picture of me roleplaying as the Quest Master “Mysterious Mark” during my Mysterious Merchant event. I gave him the personality of a seasoned guild master in the style of classic fantasy RPGs, like Dungeons and Dragons. Although I allow for some variation depending on what players ask, Mysterious Mark has set lines of dialogue and idle animations meant to imitate the quest-giver NPC stereotype. The same thing can be said for his counterpart, the Shopkeeper “Strange Stan”, who also has his own set of unique voice lines and dialogue meant to be a FOIL of Mysterious Mark’s. Furthermore, Strange Stan’s lines about each shop item are made to build out the world that Mysterious Merchant takes place in, while also giving Mysterious Mark more lore through describing how each item was found on his adventures.
Want to know more? Look here!
-
In the earliest version of Mysterious Merchant, there was actually only the quest giver, who would also serve as the way of giving out rewards.
I was eventually given the idea to create a shop and to give players gold to spend rather than directly giving the rewards. This meant that players would have the choice to purchase the item they want rather than hoping the item the got was something they’d like.
However, I quickly found out that players wouldn’t realize there was a shop, as I didn’t have anything to make it stand out at the time. My solution was to essentially add a second character who would run this shop, and giving them a far bubblier and more outgoing personality compared to the serious Mysterious Mark. I even made sure to give them a different hat to emphasize the difference between the characters.
My aim was for the shopkeeper, Strange Stan, to feel as much of an opposite to Mysterious Mark as possible. I still wanted them to feel like they were related to one another, which mostly gets told through their dialogue, but I wanted their personalities to be different enough that, even without a physical distinction, it would be obvious that they are separate characters rather than one person.
To do this, I made Strange Stan have a much higher pitched voice and be more expressive than Mysterious Mark and to have his idle animations be the opposite of Mysterious Mark. Where Mysterious Mark would pull his glove and inspect it, Strange Stan would inspect his glove and then pull it. While it is a minor detail, it would be a subtle way of further differentiating the two brothers from one another.
Although there are still times where the shop isn’t obvious, creating the shopkeeper’s character was a major success, as many players found him humorous and enjoyed the switch between characters. Having a second character also gave players the opportunity to have different conversation with each character that would feel unique rather than repeating the same info with both characters.
-
One of the reasons I find Mysterious Merchant works so well is because of the environment that it takes place in. I lean heavily on the existing video game understanding of the students at DigiPen to recognize the “quest icon” on the hat that is a widely used trope in RPGs.
Similarly, I take a very Dungeons and Dragons approach to the way I do player interactions. While there are predetermined lines of dialogue that the characters will say after certain actions, players have the agency to attempt certain actions with skill checks or ask unique questions to the NPCs.
What makes this so much more engaging than regular video game NPCs is that I have the ability to come up with unique and dedicated responses to anything players try asking me. Players can feel just a bit more immersed in the world by asking or attempting things they want to try, rather than being limited by hardware capabilities.
I have had multiple instances of players who try to get discounts on items, get more quests, or earn more gold. Letting players roll a D20 to attempt these actions makes for an even more engaging experience, as there becomes almost endless possibilities.
On that note, I have also made the quests in a way that, while some have to be taken at face value, as long as players have a reasonable explanation for why their quest item fulfills the criteria, I let players be the ones to decide how they want to complete their quests.
Some notable examples:
A player once made a sword of grass when asked to bring “a blade of grass”
A player once shone their phone light when asked to bring “something light”
A player once showed a picture of my own question mark hat when asked to bring “something with a question mark on it”
The only limitation on players is their imagination, and I found that it makes for a much more enjoyable experience for players. They get to find their own solution to the problem presented for them, and they get to come up with silly or serious answers and get rewarded either way. It means that every player can play the way they want, rather than being forced into doing something they don’t want or know how to do.
Strange Stan’s Stupendous Store
Alongside the quest giving is the corresponding shop, meant to give the players a place to spend the gold that they earn for participating. Every item has a distinct description meant to explain what it is in-universe, such as the flavored water being health potions or the 3D-printed eggs being dragon eggs. On top of that, every item in the shop has been given a gold cost and a rank requirement that incentivizes players to participate multiple times in order to earn rank ups and get more valuable items, or to get enough gold to afford items they would not otherwise be able to afford in a single playthrough. All of the lower rank items have gold costs below 5 coins so that even if someone purchases something after their first quest, they still have gold leftover to save, allowing them to return in the future and have more gold for more expensive items the next time.
Want to know more? Look here!
-
Another early trouble Mysterious Merchant had was getting players to come back more than once. Many players simply wanted to try it out once at the start and would stop there, which created a space where I would get significantly less players than I wanted, having more around 8 players each time compared to my current 15-20 players.
The first idea I tested was the creation of a shop for people to spend gold they could earn from completing quests. This had a bit of success early on, but with the limited number of items I had to sell at the time, as well as how difficult it was to get players to notice the shop, the impact was less than I had hoped for.
My second idea was the creation of loyalty cards, which was the first thing that started making a real impact. Giving players a goal to reach through completing 6 total quests was the first incentive to participate more than once. However, just having a card to stamp wouldn’t be a fully reliable way to keep players engaged.
This led to the third idea, which was to add some high value items to the store that people would want. So, I tried out adding a single wizard hat to the store every time I did Mysterious Merchant, and it became the most sought-after item in the whole store. Having a very appealing item on display solved the problem of giving players a reason to complete their loyalty cards but also encouraged saving gold to buy more expensive items.
While this did give the intended effect I was looking for, it created an entirely new problem: Players would never spend their gold in the shop. Because everyone was saving their gold to buy wizard hats, it meant that no one ever purchased any other items in the store, which led to me running out of gold more and more often, and thus having to end early due to a lack of rewards to give quest completion.
My best solution for this problem was to one: make the high-ticket items cheaper so players wouldn’t have to hoard as much gold, and two: to create cheaper trading cards that players could spend bits of their gold on to collect without being so expensive that they wouldn’t be able to save enough for the more valuable items.
-
Adding trading cards to the store was an idea I had for around two years before I finally had the time and manpower to do it. My idea for the trading cards was to create two different sets of five cards, one based on the school, and one based on Mysterious Merchant, which would serve as a way to expand upon the lore of this universe.
Initially, I had taken the time to design placeholder cards, but I felt that they weren’t of the level of quality I wanted for this event. Over time, I got some feedback from artists who were able to help me find a way to make the design of the card itself more interesting, but it still left the placeholder images that I had used. Although these images could’ve worked for what I had in mind, I really wanted to make them be more unique, and mostly so that the pictures wouldn’t just be images someone could find on Google.
To solve this problem, I took the time to hire several different artists, both from the school and alumni to each make a card or two based on the placeholders I had created. This process ended up being one of the most challenging things I had to do for Mysterious Merchant.
With so many artists hired, I had to frequently manage and check in on the progress of each picture, getting progress reports over time and having to work out payment for each individual. While I had initially wanted the deadlines to be open enough to not cause stress, I soon realized that I had to put my foot down as it got closer to the beginning of the school year.
Thankfully, almost all of the art got done in time for me to format them into their corresponding cards, which I then got printed on my own. Personally, I was extremely happy with most of the art that I got, and it made me happy that I was able to help give both students and alumni work they could show off on their own while getting paid to do it.
Bonus Information
Mysterious Merchant has been an ongoing personal project of mine for the better part of three years at school. This event has gone through several changes over the years as I began to iterate and playtest different ideas that I had to see what would incentivize people to participate more. This led to me trying out ways to encourage people to return through a loyalty/reputation system, more expensive and desirable rewards, and a trading card set for people to try and collect based on both Mysterious Merchant and the school itself. Results showed that these ideas made it much more appealing to continue to participate, as I would get repeat customers with fully completed loyalty cards, multiple people who saved up enough from quests to buy the most expensive item (the wizard hat), as well as people encouraging their friends to participate.
All of this was accomplished purely through word of mouth, as I had no form of advertising the event outside of telling anyone who asked when it would happen. Since I made these improvements, I averaged around 15 - 20 people participating every time I did the event, with many of them being new participants.
On top of all of that, I also did bits of system design with the shop, working out how much items should cost based on the amount of gold a person would have or be able to save up, designing it in such a way that almost every item would leave a person with one or two coins leftover to incentivize returning and saving their gold for the more expensive items.